Hello everyone, I had a few questions regarding the usage of 向, which appears in lesson 3.1 Catching A Ride:
http://members.rocketlanguages.com/lessons/261
According to this lesson, 向 can be translated to english as "to". In this lesson, it is used as 你可以向我推荐。。。 which means "Can you recommend to me...".
I understand clearly the usage of 向 in this sentence, and was wondering if using 向 in the following sentences would be correct as well:
- 向 [name]: (This is the typical introduction used when writing a letter, if you understand the context I'm trying to imply ).
- 给向谁?: (Give to whom? )
- 你可以向我唱歌吗 ? (Can you sing to me?)
- 你可以向他给这个吗 ? (Can you give this to him?)
And this list goes on and on, I will think of more sentences. But they generally follow the same pattern as the ones above.
Thanks in advance
Usage of 向

Jaime_Andres
May 29, 2012

Lin-Ping
June 9, 2012
你好Jaime!
The first sentence you provide, if you would like to use the word 向, you will need to change the word order to - 向谁给… To be honest, the word 向 is not used a lot in these contexts, it is used more for the movement of object or people i.e. 他向外边走。 Although the following two sentences are grammatically correct, they sound a little odd and I will provide some alternatives.
- 你可以向我唱歌吗? - 你可以给我唱歌吗? this is much more natural and you are more likely to hear this.
- 你可以向他给这个吗? - 你可以给他这个吗?
Once again, the word 向 is used more for physical movement as opposed to directing transitive verbs. If you do want to use it however, just remember the word order:
向 + somebody/something + verb
I hope this helps,
- Lin Ping

Jaime_Andres
June 19, 2012
Thank you very much Lin.