Forum Rocket Spanish Spanish - Grammar Indirect and direct object, still confusing or not?

Indirect and direct object, still confusing or not?

Chris1965

Chris1965

Hi. After having worked through the first 5 chapters of RS Beginner's grammar 3.0 I got a bit puzzled when reading the examples on the top of page 127, more specific example 2 and 5. 2. Ellos se los dicen. - They tell it to them. 5. Nosotros se los damos. - We give it to them. As I understand "se" could mean both to them, him, her and so on, so there's no problem with the indirect object but... In both the Spanish sentences "los" (plural) is direct object, right? In the English translation the direct objects are referred to as "it" (sing.) Shouldn't it say "them" like - They tell *them*(f.ex.the secrets) to them - and -We give *them* to them - ?? Am I completely lost or not? :shock: Confused
Alan-LaCala

Alan-LaCala

I think it is due to the fact that when an indirect obect pronoun is used with a direct object pronoun, if the indirect object pronoun is *le *or l*es*, then it changes to *se*. Alan
Chris1965

Chris1965

Thanks for your answer. But... It's not "se" and the indirect object, that bothers me. I still think that the plural of the direct objects "los" in the Spanish got lost in translation and became singular "it" in the English sentences. My opinion is still that the "it"s in both these sentences are direct objects. Greetings from Norway Chris
Spanish-Landy

Spanish-Landy

Chris, I agree with you. Perhaps the example was translated as "it" to avoid any confusion with the indirect object translation. Whatever the reason, I think you are correct. Or at least that is how I have come to understand it. S.L.
Chris1965

Chris1965

Let's cling to that :D , at least as long as no one proves otherwise. And.. thanks for replying. Chris

Ask a question or post a response

If you want to ask a question or post a response you need to be a member.

If you are already a member login here.
If you are not a member you can become one by taking the free Rocket Spanish trial here.